Eagles Building Case for Nick Sirianni’s Return

The Philadelphia Eagles have lost seven consecutive games and are in last place in the NFC East. Therefore, many are calling for Eagles head coach Nick Sirianni to be fired — despite all of his success in Philadelphia. Yet the franchise’s top decision makers appear to be building their own case to support the potential return of Sirianni as the team’s head coach in 2027.

Here are six reasons why the Eagles could run it back with Sirianni next season.

Unforeseen Circumstances Aided Collapse

The Eagles entered the regular season with Super Bowl aspirations, which was part of the reason why All-Pro starting right tackle Lane Johnson decided to return for one final season. Yet after a 2-1 start to the regular season, Johnson understandably decided to retire to focus on his family and life away from the football field. Johnson’s retirement was unexpected and the team’s record with and without him proves just how important he is to the Eagles.

Since Johnson was drafted in 2013, Philadelphia is 122-63-1 in games that he’s played and 18-30 in games that he’s missed. The loss of Johnson cannot be overstated and the same can be said for starting quarterback Jalen Hurts. The 28-year-old former Super Bowl MVP was unexpectedly lost for the season due to blood clots. Therefore, Philadelphia was suddenly down their two most important players just five weeks into the regular season.

Despite losing both Johnson and Hurts, Philadelphia has also been without several other key starters due to injuries throughout this season. While the team’s struggles date back to the second half of last season, I could see Eagles owner Jeffrey Lurie and general manager Howie Roseman using the team’s unfortunate injury luck as an excuse for Sirianni. Yet there’s an argument to be made that Philadelphia has been unsustainably healthy during Sirianni’s tenure and it was bound to catch up with them eventually.

Over the Top Trade Offers Hindered Roster

Following the team’s 2-2 start to the regular season, Roseman made an unexpected trade that many couldn’t fault him for. The Eagles sent starting left guard Cam Jurgens and a 2027 seventh-round pick to the Baltimore Ravens in exchange for a 2027 fifth-round pick and a 2028 second-round pick. It was an incredible return for what appeared to be a declining player — yet it proved to be a sign of things to come.

Prior to the NFL’s trade deadline, Roseman made another unexpected trade. The Eagles sent starting interior defensive lineman and team captain Jordan Davis to the Jacksonville Jaguars for a 2027 first-round pick and a 2029 second-round pick. Similar to the Jurgens’ trade, it was hard to dispute the return that Philadelphia received. Yet moving on from another long-time starter could help shield Sirianni.

Following the NFL’s trade deadline, Philadelphia waived two veterans in Hollywood Brown and Fred Johnson. This unofficial teardown feels like a way to create another convenient excuse to keep Sirianni around in 2027. How can the team truly expect him to turn things around while down several key players and now along with various other changes? It feels like another part of their growing sales pitch to the fans.

High-Priced Bill Is Past Due

Philadelphia’s use of void years is well-documented and the bill continues to increase. While many will say that it doesn’t have any real impact on the team’s spending, we’re seeing that line of thinking isn’t entirely true in 2026. The Eagles have essentially been forced to carry Johnson on the 53-man roster — despite that he’s stepped away — because of how his contract is structured. That’s a direct impact of the team’s use of void years and roster bonuses.

We also saw the Eagles reportedly turn down trade offers for veteran tight end Dallas Goedert, possibly due to the structure of his contract. If Philadelphia traded Goedert now, it would result in a larger dead cap hit than they would hypothetically take on in the offseason. Now the Eagles could be possibly dealing with another huge financial hit — if they were to fire Sirianni. While Sirianni’s contract doesn’t count against the salary cap, it’s still a significant amount of money.

According to multiple reports, Sirianni makes $15 million per season from the Eagles. If Philadelphia were to move on from him, they would still owe him the remainder of that contract, along with whatever they’re going to spend on his replacement. Lurie already shells out a ton of cash for the use of void years, which is starting to catch up to the team. I could see the money owed to Sirianni playing a role in him sticking around.

Sirianni Is Close Friends With Shane Steichen

One of the biggest criticisms during Sirianni’s tenure has been the team’s reliance on proven offensive coordinators. After the franchise swung and missed by chasing a scheme with the hire of Sean Mannion, Philadelphia could turn to a familiar face. With many expecting the Indianapolis Colts to fire head coach Shane Steichen — the Eagles use Sirianni’s presence and close relationship with Steichen as a sales pitch to bring him back to the City of Brotherly Love.

Assuming that Hurts is going to return as the team’s starting quarterback in 2027, Steichen has already shown that he can get the most out of him. Given that Steichen would be coming off of just being fired by the Colts, it would make it less likely that he would then receive another head coaching job in 2028. If Philadelphia can use Sirianni’s relationship with Steichen to lure him back for at least two more seasons, some skeptical fans may buy into that idea.

Steichen Can Mend Fences With Jeff Stoutland

Another common criticism of Sirianni in 2026 has been the offseason departure of former Eagles offensive line coach Jeff Stoutland. According to multiple reports, Stoutland was stripped of his run coordinator duties in 2025 and wasn’t ready to take a backseat on a revamped offensive coaching staff this season. Yet if Steichen returns to Philadelphia, could he be the middle man to help mend the fences with Stoutland?

The two seemingly worked well together in 2021 and in 2022 — maybe they’ll be willing to run it back again in 2027. While some fans may be scared to lose Steichen again, the possibility of Stoutland returning alongside him could make it all worth it. If Sirianni returns, the concerns about the offensive staff around him would certainly be alleviated with the return of two familiar (and beloved) faces.

Jim Schwartz Willing To Return

Earlier in the offseason, Eagles legendary defensive coordinator Vic Fangio was reportedly contemplating retirement. While Fangio was weighing his options, Philadelphia reportedly considered hiring former Browns defensive coordinator Jim Schwartz to replace him, according to Jimmy Kempski of PhillyVoice. Fast forward to the bye week and Fangio certainly seems like he’s ready to call it a career.

If that’s the case, the Eagles will have massive shoes to fill at defensive coordinator. But if Philadelphia was already considering pursuing a reunion with Schwartz on Sirianni’s staff — they could certainly do so again in 2027. While it would be tough to sell fans on Sirianni returning as the team’s head coach, it would potentially be more palatable if the Eagles were able to bring back two coordinators that have already had plenty of success in Philadelphia.

Previous
Previous

Eagles Poaching List: 10 Practice Squad Targets

Next
Next

Eagles Mailbag: What’s the Plan Going Forward?